| Platinum | Apricot Tree Cafe |
| Gold | Lazar Famous Deli & Bakery |
| Silver | Craveables Cafe |
| Bronze | Tribeca Coffee Co. |
| Top Pick | BukaMaranga |
| Top Pick | Cong Caphe |
| Top Pick | Daly Grind Cafe |
| Top Pick | Danish Pastry House |
| Top Pick | PortChops - Café & Bistrô |
| Top Pick | Tea One Bakery and Cafe |