| Platinum | Vito's |
| Gold | St. Louis Bar & Grill |
| Silver | Wingporium |
| Bronze | Allstar Wings Express |
| Top Pick | AllStar Ribs & Wings |
| Top Pick | Lionheart British Pub & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Roc'N Doc's Bar And Grill |
| Top Pick | The Port House Social Bar & Kitchen |
| Top Pick | The Wilcox Gastropub |
| Top Pick | Turtle Jack's |
