| Platinum | Great Canadian Pizza |
| Gold | Amadio's Pizza |
| Silver | Pizzeria Rosso |
| Bronze | Doughboys Port Credit |
| Top Pick | Goodfellas Wood Oven Pizza |
| Top Pick | La Villa Bakery & Café |
| Top Pick | Papa Giuseppe's |
| Top Pick | Pizzaiolo |
| Top Pick | San Francesco Foods |
| Top Pick | Thyme Ristorante |
